All-Americans
| Athlete | Year | Organization | Sport/Event | Team |
| Isaiah Acfalle | 2017 | AVCA NAIA | Men's Volleyball | HM |
| Morgan Bradford | 2012 | NAIA | Oudoor T&F/Pole Vault | |
| Emily Brown | 2008 | NAIA | Indoor T&F/Weight Throw | |
| Emily Brown | 2008 | NAIA | Outdoor T&F/Hammer | |
| Emily Brown | 2009 | NAIA | Indoor T&F/Weight Throw | |
| Emily Brown | 2009 | NAIA | Outdoor T&F/Hammer | |
| Krista Bushkofsky | 2016 | NAIA | Indoor T&F/60m Hurdles | 7th Place |
| Krista Bushkofsky | 2017 | NAIA | Indoor T&F/60m Hurdles | 4th Place |
| DeMonte Bynum | 2008 | NAIA | Basketball | 2nd |
| Sarah Crews | 2017 | NAIA | Softball | HM |
| Kasey Davis | 2019 | NAIA | Women's Volleyball | 3rd |
| Kelsey Ernst | 2017 | NAIA | Basketball | 3rd |
| Kohl Gregory | 2016 | NAIA | Outdoor T&F/High Jump | |
| Makenna Haase | 2018 | NAIA | Basketball | HM |
| Makenna Haase | 2019 | NAIA | Basketball | 2nd |
| Makenna Haase | 2020 | NAIA | Basketball | 2nd |
| Makenna Haase | 2021 | NAIA | Basketball | 3rd |
| Mikayla Houston | 2018 | NAIA | Indoor Track/Weight Throw | 7th Place |
| Mikayla Houston | 2019 | NAIA | Indoor Track/Weight Throw | 5th Place |
| Breanna Judkins | 2018 | NAIA | Triple Jump | 3rd Place |
| Breanna Judkins | 2019 | NAIA | Outdoor Track/Triple Jump | 6th Place |
| Breanna Judkins | 2020 | NAIA | Indoor Track/Triple Jump | 6th |
| Shelby Kline | 2021 | NAIA | Outdoor Track/Steeplechase | 4th |
| Preston Kopp | 2015 | NAIA | Outdoor Track/Hammer | |
| Preston Kopp | 2017 | NAIA | Outdoor Track/Hammer | |
| Elle Kosciuk | 2013 | AVCA NAIA & Tachikara-NAIA | Volleyball | HM |
| Chantel Kyler | 2019 | NAIA | Indoor Track/High Jump | 5th Place |
| Chantel Kyler | 2019 | NAIA | Outdoor Track/High Jump | 8th Place |
| Michael Lopez | 2017 | NAIA | Baseball | HM |
| Jessica Nessan | 2010 | NAIA | Indoor Trace/Long Jump | 7th |
| Nick Peterson | 2020 | NAIA | Indoor Track, Pole Vault | 7th |
| Morgan Pitz | 2019 | NAIA | Basketball | HM |
| Breland Prochaska | 2015 | NAIA | Basketball | HM |
| Dino Ramic | 2011 | NAIA | Soccer | HM |
| Andrew Redman | 2015 | NAIA | Baseball | HM |
| Keith Sanders | 1986 | Nat'l. Little College | Basketball | |
| Demetriyone Singleton | 2015 | NAIA | Outdoor T&F/100m Hurdles | 2nd Place |
| Haris Takes | 2018 | NAIA | Basketball | HM |
| Josh Udelhofen | 2013 | GCAA | Golf | 3rd |
| Erik Vogt | 2006 | AVCA/Division III | Volleyball | |
| Rhonda Weaver | 1987 | Nat'l. Little College | Cross Country | |
| Tyler Wills | 2012 | AVCA/NAIA | Volleyball | |
| Tyler Wills | 2013 | AVCA/NAIA | Volleyball | |
| Tyler Wills | 2014 | AVCA/NAIA | Volleyball | |
| Tyler Wills | 2015 | AVCA/NAIA | Volleyball | |
| Quentin Yoerger | 1987 | Nat'l. Little College | Cross Country |