All Conference
| 2008-09 | Russ ReVoir | Outdoor Track | All-Conference |
| Issac Mase | Outdoor Track | All-Conference | |
| 2009-10 | Justin Heng | Outdoor Track, 800m | All-Conference |
| 2010-11 | Graham Mahon | Indoor Track, 800m | All-Conference |
| Charles Deneen | Indoor Track, High Jump | All-Conference | |
| 2011-12 | Graham Mahon | Indoor Track | All-Conference |
| Russ ReVoir | Outdoor Track | All-Conference | |
| 2012-13 | Gavin Dedering | Indoor Track, Pole Vault | All-Conference |
| Tyler Ernst | Indoor Track, 55M Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Paul Cave | Outdoor Track, 400M Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Gavin Dedering | Outdoor Track, Pole Vault | All-Conference | |
| Graham Mahon | Outdoor Track, 800M Run | All-Conference | |
| 2013-14 | Nick Anderson | Indoor, 4x400 Meter Relay | All-Conference |
| Josh Bellows | Indoor, Distance Medley Relay | All-Conference | |
| Paul Cave | Indoor 4x400 Meter Relay | All-Conference | |
| Tyler Ernst | Indoor 60 Meter Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Chase Gregory | Indoor4x800 Meter Relay | All-Conference | |
| Kohl Gregory | Indoor High Jump | All-Conference | |
| Stacy Latnie | Indoor 4x800 Meter Relay, Distance Medley | All-Conference | |
| Graham Mahon | Indoor4x800 Meter Relay, Distance Medley | All-Conference | |
| Zach Molid | Indoor 4x800 Meter Relay | All-Conference | |
| Patrick Rothery | Indoor Distance Medley Relay | All-Conference | |
| Mark Schmidt | Indoor Pole Vault | All-Conference | |
| Taylor Shively | Indoor 4x400 Meter Relay | All-Conference | |
| Demetriyone Singleton | Indoor 60 Meter Hurdles | HM All-Conference | |
| Brendan Walters | Indoor Long Jump, 4x400 Meter Relay | All-Conference | |
| Trey Wiedmann | Indoor Triple Jump | All-Conference | |
| Paul Cave | Outdoor 400 Meter Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Tyler Ernst | Outdoor 110 Meter Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Kohl Gregory | Outdoor High Jump | All-Conference | |
| Mark Schmidt | Outdoor Pole Vault | All-Conference | |
| Trey Wiedmann | Outdoor Triple Jump | All-Conference | |
| 2014-2015 | Nicholas Anderson | Indoor 800M Run | All-Conference |
| Nicholas Anderson | Indoor Distance Medley Relay | All-Conference | |
| Nick Anderson | Indoor Distance Medley Relay | All-Conference | |
| Malik McCrary | Indoor Distance Medley Relay | All-Conference | |
| Brendan Walters | Indoor Distance Medley Relay | All-Conference | |
| Taurus Black | Indoor 60M Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Mark Schmidt | Indoor Pole Vault | All-Conference | |
| Trey Wiedmann | Indoor Triple Jump | All-Conference | |
| Nicholas Anderson | Outdoor 800M Run | All-Conference | |
| Nicholas Anderson | Outdoor 4x800 Relay | All-Conference | |
| Nick Anderson | Outdoor 4x800 Relay | All-Conference | |
| Malik McCrary | Outdoor 4x800 Relay | All-Conference | |
| David Meyers | Outdoor 4x800 Relay | All-Conference | |
| Paul Cave | Outdoor 400M Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Kohl Gregory | Outdoor High Jump | All-Conference | |
| Luke North | Outdoor Half Marathon | All-Conference | |
| Mark Schmidt | Outdoor Pole Vault | All-Conference | |
| Demetriyone Singleton | Outdoor 110M Hurdles | All-Conference | |
| Trey Wiedmann | Outdoor Triple Jump | All-Conference | |
| 2015-2016 | Craig Stout | Indoor 5000M Run | All-Conference |
| Trey Wiedmann | Indoor Triple Jump | All-Conference | |
| 2016-2017 | Nick Peterson | Outdoor Pole Vault | All-Conference |
| 2017-18 | Nicholas Anderson | 4x800 m, 600m run, 800m run- Indoor | Honorable Mention |
| Malik McCrary | 4x800 relay, 800m run, 1000m run- Indoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Kevin Ockenfels | 4x800 relay, 1000m run- Indoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Jimmy Slowik | 4x800 relay- Indoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Danny Martin | Pole Vault- Indoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Sawyer Foss | Shot Put- Indoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Nick Peterson | Pole Vault- Outdoor | Second Team | |
| Kevin Ockenfels | 4x800 relay- Outdoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Jimmy Slowik | 4x800 relay- Outdoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Malik McCrary | 4x800 relay- Outdoor | Honorable Mention | |
|
Nicholas Anderson |
4x800 relay- Outdoor | Honorable Mention | |
| Danny Martin | Pole Vault- Outdoor | Honorable Mention |